Why do nice guys get such a bad rap? I used to feel sorry for my self-proclaimed nice guy friends who would bemoan their poor treatment from women who “always” went for the “bad boy.” These nice guys would get ditched for a guy who apparently wasn’t quite so nice. Boo hoo.
A few years ago I fell for a nice guy. He treated me like a goddess. He was my biggest fan. There wasn’t anything I could say or do that wasn’t brilliant or an accomplishment. For those who know me, you know how I initially reacted.
“Finally! Someone who really understands me!”
Our relationship really was all about me – what I wanted, where I wanted to go, which movie I wanted to see, which sandwich I wanted to split. If you’ve ever seen the movie, Lars and the Real Girl, you’ll understand, except that I was with my Real Boy. The two of us were a reflection of me. I really didn’t know who he was inside.
But he was definitely nice.
The man I love isn’t what I’d call nice. He’s polite, kind, generous, and compassionate. He’s funny, smart, edgy, and a risk taker. He’s like a paint-by-number kit with every color under the sun vs. shades of gray. We don’t always agree and it doesn’t bother either one of us. But I wouldn’t just call him a nice guy.
Why do women go for the bad boy? (And for the record, I’m not talking about mean or abusive men.) I’ll speak for myself here. Bad boys fascinate me. They aren’t trying to impress or flatter. They are wholly themselves and know how to have fun. These guys aren’t hiding behind a mask, nervous that their opinions or needs will be unsatisfactory. As for me, give me smart and funny – throw in compassionate and generous, and I’m there every time.
But don’t just try to be smart and funny, compassionate and generous, if in reality you are not. In the words of Oscar Wilde, “Be yourself. Everyone else is taken.”

Love is such a mysterious and unknowable thing. Almost a concept that cannot be defined. We all for some reason or another find things attractive in the opposite sex that are unique to our own needs. Finding one who is our “souls mate” is as elusive as the proverbial needle in a haystack. After 28 years of marriage, I now find myself seeking characteristics that my wife didn’t have, and honestly, I can’t figure out exactly what it is I am looking for. I have become a “bad boy” (by your definition) of sorts, in that I am reluctant about making close connections with women and I never fail speak my mind. Consequently, I tend shoot myself in the foot when it comes to women I might have otherwise discovered to be THE ONE(S).
Tell the truth in love, right? I value honesty, even about the micro-issues. I want to know how someone feels upfront if he/she feels it is important. I’m looking for openness and a willingness to share … in my friends and in my future best friend and lover.
I understand what you are saying. I have been there too and can say that given the choice, I like a challenge. Meaning, I like a person that will challenge me, not always make things about me and what I want, but who isn’t afraid to rub me the wrong way if I make he doesn’t agree. I like the slightly bad boy anyday.
Hey, do you have a new love interest? Not sure if you are being literal. If so, he sounds like Mr. Wonderful … more juice please. 😉
The French Psychoanalyst Lacan said that woman seeks a powerful man to control. That’s what women want in a man: power. It can take the form of wealth, political sway, rebellious demeanor, etc, but the man must be sufficient and somewhat exploitable by love.
the nice guy also has adrenaline and hence aggression, but since he is castrated by “niceness,” his aggression is expressed as passive-aggressiveness, in a feminine manner.
Men want beauty, youth, and mystery, women want power, courage, and independence. These are basic.
The nice guy is just as cruel as the bold man, but he expresses it indirectly rather than rudely. Some women prefer that. Others, like you, do not.
Daniel, I was sooooo bored by this guy. As I finally said to him after we broke up, “As fascinating as I am, I don’t need to just focus on me.” All the responsibility for the relationship fell on my shoulders, he just followed. I don’t know about him being passive-aggressive, I think he was just passive-passive. And I’m not looking for cruelty, just someone who has their own form of fascination that will draw me in as well.