Nothing like a little drama to shine the light on gender topics. We can thank WNBA top draft pick, Caitlyn Carter, for being in the latest gender pay  inequity spotlight and bringing this topic to the forefront, where it belongs. 

Just like any negative situation, shining a light into dark corners can help bring about positive change.

Employees talking about money is usually taboo, often causing frustration and broken relationships.

I recently did a Facebook poll to see what people had to say about whether or not they shared their compensation with colleagues, friends, and/or family.

“Never! Don’t need drama.”

“I mentioned what I was making per hour to one of my co-workers, she had been working there much longer than I had. I was making more than her and she confronted the boss about it. I got my butt chewed out as it was none of her business to know.”

“In my company we share everyone’s salary and the entire profit and loss statement, including the company’s net profit, with everyone.”

“Other employees, absolutely, after I get to know them. A good way of realizing if you or they are being screwed over.”

“Transparency is always my preference especially because women tend to get hurt more when there isn’t. And yet, it remains taboo!”

Salary Transparency

What is Salary Transparency? Salary transparency is complete knowledge shared in a company regarding compensation, at all levels. This is 100% transparent.

States, cities and municipalities are beginning to enact laws to require levels of pay transparency, and individual requirements differ greatly:

Because this is requiring that companies meet the letter of the law, not the intent, often only the minimum required is provided. Ranges can be as meaningless as $90,000 to $900,000. 

An interesting twist is that employers can be forbidden to request prior pay information. When companies request a candidate’s salary history, that can be a tool to calculate the job offer, versus offering the salary appropriate to the job itself. When a candidate is currently unemployed, this takes advantage of their desire to be employed. This is the most promising part of current legislation, as it actually works in the employee’s best interest.

Talking is Taboo

Talking about money has been considered taboo for generations.  Proper etiquette taught that well-mannered people don’t talk about money. A majority of people feel their value is tied to their compensation and financial wherewithal, and don’t want to feel ashamed to find out where they rank in their social (friend and colleague) hierarchy. 

The 1935 National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) grants employees the right to talk to their coworkers about pay. But companies still benefit from the “taboo” scenario because employees fear reprisals, even if they won’t actually be punished. Employees resist being labeled a trouble maker, or someone who tries to stir up drama.

Why It’s Important

2024 Equal Pay Day is March 12, 2024. If you’re not familiar with Equal Pay Day, this is an annual calculation performed since 1996 by the National Committee on Pay Equity, sharing how much longer into the following year women need to work to earn what men earned the previous 12 months. For women of color, the dates can go into September. 

The 2024 Equal Pay Day is March 12, 2024.

What happens when we are transparent about salary?

  1. We shine a light on wage gaps as they currently exist
  2. Transparency dilutes the stigma or taboo of talking about pay
  3. Employees get a better understanding of the different components of pay, such as job experience, education, skills, and longevity. Employees can be paid differently, just not based on gender, skin color, or any of many biases.
  4. Companies can be held accountable to pay their “most valuable asset” appropriately and fairly. 

The Path to Becoming Salary Transparent

Become Your Own Advocate

It would appear that many employees resist pay transparency as much as employers. The best way to feel more comfortable with salary transparency is to become your own advocate, being more open to discussing pay as well as understanding the nuances of different pay scales.

Take the first step which is to become familiar with your current job pay, from an industry and market standpoint as well as competitors. Get industry and market information online from sources such as LinkedIn, Glassdoor, and Indeed. Check out postings of competitors for your position to see what they offer. Surprisingly, you may find your own employer posting your similar position at a higher pay. (This is common due to market fluctuations that leave existing workforce compensation behind.)

Look at your own resume. Highlight your skills, education, accomplishments and career path. Begin to feel more comfortable with the compensation process versus simply trusting the numbers provided by your employer. 

In the past, companies have promoted themselves as a second “family”, encouraging loyalty and trust. This can be a false trust at times.

Authentic trust is like any strong relationship. Strong, trusting relationships have full disclosure, openness, transparency, a willingness to discuss and make changes that benefit the relationship.

It’s Not Personal

Accept the concept that pay inequities currently exist. Your own compensation may be higher or lower than someone else. Often, this is a function of job market fluctuations. The truth is, new employees often start at higher compensation than existing employees with more experience. Instead of complaining, use the research steps noted above and make sure you are being paid at market for your experience and skill level versus waiting for your employer to correct the situation.

When you are able to move into a place of more neutrality, you move away from being emotionally attached to your compensation. Your pay is not an indicator of your self-worth. The reality is, your compensation is the price you accept for the work you do. Similar to the price of a vehicle, home, or even vacation, there’s a monetary exchange. Neutrality gives you more power to negotiate and to see your pay as an exchange for your work value.

Use the Tools

Being willing to ask for what you deserve allows you to find out how your company responds. The best course is to present what you’ve learned, explaining the value you bring and the market price of your skill set. Don’t threaten to quit. Don’t look for another job and bring in an ultimatum for negotiating power. If you’re not satisfied with the response to your request, you can use your research and updated resume to look at options.

Share With Your Friends and Coworkers

How do we break this toxic cycle of pay inequity and silence? When you’re open with your friends and coworkers, you become more comfortable with the conversation. You also help shine a light on current wage gaps. 

What’s the best way to get started? Realize that you aren’t sharing with an intent to manipulate or embarrass others. Make time for a conversation with a trusted friend or colleague. Explain your process, the research and your updated resume. Share your market value and current compensation, plus any steps you’ve taken for an increase, if appropriate. Without demanding that they share, explain that you’re working on getting more comfortable with pay transparency because it ultimately helps everyone get paid fairly. 

You are ultimately the only one in charge of your career. Choose what you want and the value you bring.

When you are your own advocate in the workplace, you ultimately decide what you will accept. You realize you are in control of your career, how you want to progress, what skills and knowledge you want to acquire, and the price you charge for the value you bring.

I’d love your feedback! Have you talked to others about your pay? Have you researched your market value?

Are you already a VIP Subscriber to my weekly Winning at Work newsletter? If not, you can elevate your week with inspirational content sent directly to your email inbox. Invest just two minutes for a dose of motivation! Click here to subscribe!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *